With the growing popularity of foot fitness and barefoot training within the health & fitness industry, professionals are beginning to appreciate the impact that improper foot function can have on lower extremity alignment and total body function.
To truly understand the connection between feet and function, an understanding of the different foot types and foot imbalances is imperative. In all EBFA courses and Certification workshops we educate professionals on the basics to performing both open-chain and closed-chain foot assessments.
The goal of these assessment techniques is to build an appreciation for the unique differences each person can have in foot mobility, structure and function.
To date, most of my EBFA Blog posts have been about the pes planus or flat foot. But the impact that a caves or high arched foot type can have on alignment and functional movement is just as important to understand.
The Cavus / Inverted Foot
When we look at a true cavus or high arched foot there are some characteristic joint alignment issues that should begin to jump out at you.
1. Inverted STJ
As we look at the cavus foot from behind, it is quite apparent that the heel is turned in or inverted. This STJ position causes the navicular bone to sit in a position that is superior to that of the cuboid – causing the mid foot to excessively lock. Remember that it the unlocking of the mid foot that allows our foot to loading impact forces and use them for potential energy and efficient movement.
This increased STJ inversion can be the result of an imbalance between the muscles on the inside of the ankle (posterior tibialis and anterior tibialis) and the muscles on the outside of the ankle (peroneals) – or it could be a compensation for a plantar flexed 1st ray in the forefoot (more on this soon).
2. Increased calcaneal inclination and metatarsal declination
As we look at the foot from the side what gives this increased appearance of the high arch is what called the “pitch” or inclination of the heel bone relative to the declination of the metatarsals.
In the Xray below we see the altered pitch in both the calcaneus and metatarsals. Not only does this alter the osseous or bone structure of the foot, but soft tissue compensations and contractures are going to follow.
This increased metatarsal declination angle along with weakened foot intrinsics alters the muscle balance of the extensor digitorum longus (EDL) allowing hyperextenion and contracture of the digits. Furthermore the plantar flexed metatarsals lead to plantar fascia shortening which further locks the foot and impairs the foots ability to load and unload impact forces.
3. Plantarflexed 1st Metatarsal
The final characteristic of a cavus or high arched foot can be a plantar flexed first ray. The 1st ay includes the great toe, first metatarsal and medial cuneiform bone. If we load the foot in an open chain assessment we can see how a plantar flexed first ray would present.
In the case of a plantar flexed first ray when the foot tries to establish a tripod, the plantar flexed 1st ray shifts the bodyweight onto the lateral aspect of the foot causing compensatory inversion of the heel or STJ. This STJ eversion and over-activation of the tibialis anterior further locks the foot and adducts the forefoot relative to the rear foot.
One of the tests that can be done to see if the plantar flexed first ray is driving the STJ inversion is called a Coleman Block Test.
In this test, the client / patients stands with just the first ray off of the block. If the STJ neutralizes during this test then it is confirmed that – 1. the plantar flexed first ray is in fact driving the STJ inversion and 2. that it is a flexible and correctable deformity (often with orthotics). This test is covered in advanced EBFA workshops.
Foot-Specific Programming for Functional Movement
So what do you do if you have a client or patient with this foot type?
Understanding the unique imbalances presented in this foot type are important to correcting the efficiency of movement and restoring balance in the cavus foot type.
1. Improving foot mobility
Because the invertors play an important role in shock absorption, over-activity of these muscle make this foot type a poor shock absorber. Clients with this foot type may tell you they have a history of stress fractures or shin splints.
Fitness Rx: To relax the over-activity of the inverters, integrate myofascial release into your client’s program. I like to address the posterior tibialis muscle by going to the bottom of the foot. Remember that the posterior tibialis has 9 attachments that fan the bottom of the foot. Standing on a golf ball is one of my favorite release techniques for the plantar foot.
Reccommended 5 minutes every morning, evening and before working out.
2. Improving lateral ankle stability
Normal walking and running require our foot to strike the ground in an inverted position. With the over-supinated heel already in an inverted position, the chances of twisting or rolling an ankle are even greater in this foot type.
Typically the muscles on the outside of our ankle (peroneals) function to stabilize and prevent the ankle from rolling, however in the over-supinated foot type they are already eccentrically loaded and therefore cannot function properly to prevent ankle sprains.
Fitness Rx: To relax the eccentrically active peroneals integrate myofascial release into your client’s programming. Because the peroneals are elongated in a cavus foot type you do not want to stretch an already elongated muscle. Stretching an elongated muscle can increase the tension placed on the tendon leading to further instability or tendonitis.
I would follow the myofascial release of the peroneals with intrinsic strengthening. This intrinsic strengthening should be done in a controlled setting as to avoid over-activation and further locking of the foot. I recommend integrating balance exercises and movement patterns with short foot activation during the concentric phase of the exercise. For examples of these exercises please visit: YouTube Video
3. Increase LPH Mobility
Ensuring proper foot mobility also requires an assessment of lumbopelvic hip mobility. Through the lateral myofascial highway, the taut peronals in an over-supinated foot type will begin to pull on the iliotibial band. With its attachment to the tensor fascia lata on the anterior hip, an over-supinated foot type can cause secondary pelvic immobility.
I often tell professionals in my workshops that the foot and hip are like a marriage. If someone has a locked foot and ankle you can usually assume their LPH complex will also be restricted.
Fitness Rx: To increase LPH mobility in a cavus foot type, integrate TFL myofascial release into your client’s programming. I recommend following TFL, anterior hip release with dynamic stretches. This can be locked in with pelvic floor activation and deep hip stabilization.
To learn more about the implications of different foot types please visit http://www.ebfafitness.com
6 Comments Add yours
Any type of ARCH SUPPORT OR INSERT would help?
Hi Luis – if the driver in this foot type is the plantar flexed first ray then yes an orthotic with a reverse morton’s extension or first ray cut-out would allow the STJ to neutralize thereby improving biomechanics. IF this is not the driven than an insert that is accommodative to take pressure off of the metatarsal heads would be of benefit. Hope this helps! Thank you for reading – Dr Emily
Long time ago at UCLA I learned how to make the UCBL FOOT INSERT from the man who invented them (John Campbell) and he said that those inserts can be used to increase or decrease the arch depending how we take the plaster mold; I have made maybe 500 of those foot inserts but always to correct flat foot and never to lower the arch….regards, Luis.
Hello Luis – the UCBL would not be used in this patient. I typically prescribe UCBL for the pediatric flat foot as it gives a lot of control with the medial / lateral flanges. For cavus foot think more what I stated in the previous comment! Dr E
Hi, I have very high arches and also very thin fat pads on my feet. I wore orthotics for years and then after an ankle injury it’s like my foot started to repel them. I have been doing tons of research on barefoot training, doing lots of body work to try and change y structure and everyone tells me to stay out of orthotics. I am losing hope. I am only 40 and can barely walk. Would you suggest orthotics for me?
Hello Krista – orthotics are meant to control foot biomechanics. There is another type of insert that is more accommodative which usually made of memory foam or plastazote. With your foot type and thinning fat pads I recommend trying this type of insert vs. a traditional orthotics that is trying to control your biomechanics. You may also want to try a metatarsal pad on the inserts. Good luck – Dr Splichal